Dan Saffer’s new book, Designing for Interaction, is a little, well, odd.
On the one hand, it evangelizes the practice of interaction design quite well, explaining in great detail what it is people like Saffer (a designer for Adaptive Path) and myself do for a living. It tells the back story of the profession, defines what it means to be an interaction designer, and even goes into some of the details, like interface design basics, the elements of interaction, the principles and laws that are involved, and so on. For these reasons, it’s a book worth having on the shelf.
On the other hand, because it focuses too much on defining the field and craft of interaction design instead of how to put it into practice, it’s basically a 250-page job description and doesn’t quite give readers something to use. It reminds me a bit of those books you read when you’re a kid about what a fireman does and how he puts out fires. Not necessarily a bad thing - as I’ve said, it’s a book worth having on the shelf - but not what I expected at all.
Why didn’t I expect such a simple book? Because Adaptive Path and Dan Saffer have gone to great lengths to promote the hell out of it. In fact, the great promotional effort is the only reason I feel compelled to write about it. If it wasn’t for all the hype, I wouldn’t even care.
The book has received gushing reviews from people like Jesse James Garrett and Jared Spool, has been parlayed into a series of conference sessions and day-long workshops, and is getting a release party thrown for it in San Francisco (hosted by Adaptive Path).
Simply put, I don’t get it. I don’t get why this particular book has earned itself such credibility amongst Saffer’s peers in the profession. Is it simply because he works for Adaptive Path, works with Jesse James Garrett, and knows Jared Spool? In other words, is it just because he knows people in the business who were willing to give it high praise?
Designing for Interaction is poised to be somewhat of a success in academia. People studying to become interaction designers in college will want to read it, and people teaching classess about it will want to cite it. But if you’re out in the real world already, I’m just not sure it can be marketed in a way that appeals to its intended audience.